There is a growing backlash against ESG, particularly in conservative states of the United States. Laws limiting ESG considerations in state fund investments have been enacted in places like Idaho and North Dakota. In fossil fuel-dependent states like Texas, Oklahoma, and West Virginia, laws prevent business dealings with entities that “boycott” fossil fuel companies.
There is a growing backlash against ESG, particularly in conservative states of the United States. Laws limiting ESG considerations in state fund investments have been enacted in places like Idaho and North Dakota. In fossil fuel-dependent states like Texas, Oklahoma, and West Virginia, laws prevent business dealings with entities that “boycott” fossil fuel companies.
ESG serves as a valuable tool for businesses and investors in managing risks. Climate change, unethical practices, and poor corporate governance are among many ESG issues that present potential risks to businesses and economies. As climate change impacts intensify, particularly in industries like commercial real estate (CRE) and wholesale distribution (WSD), companies need to address physical and transition climate risks.
For example, the WSD sector plays a pivotal role in mitigating climate change risks, as logistics and manufacturing contribute significantly to global carbon emissions. Compliance with regulations, such as energy codes and environmental disclosures, is vital for avoiding legal and reputational risks.
Additionally, embracing ESG often translates to market competitiveness. Businesses that prioritize ESG often experience lower vacancy rates, higher rental premiums, and improved occupancy rates in green buildings. Furthermore, diversity in the workplace is linked to higher profitability, and consumers increasingly value sustainability and social responsibility. Transitioning to Renewable Energy To combat climate change effectively, the global economy must transition away from fossil fuels. Studies suggest that the benefits of limiting global warming to 2°C outweigh the costs of mitigation, and failing to do so could have severe economic consequences. This transition is a fundamental part of ESG strategies. Companies and investors alike recognize that sustainable practices are not only responsible but also financially savvy. As governments and international bodies intensify their efforts to combat climate change, businesses that align with these goals stand to benefit.
Some states have recognized the potential negative impact of anti-ESG legislation on investments and economies. Cost estimates for states with such bills suggest significant financial burdens on taxpayers. In March 2023, President Biden vetoed a bill that would have restricted ESG considerations in investment decisions, highlighting the importance of ESG factors in financial markets.
This demonstrates that ESG is not merely a matter of preference; it is a financially material consideration. Climate change and other ESG issues present real risks and opportunities that businesses and investors cannot afford to ignore.
Some states have recognized the potential negative impact of anti-ESG legislation on investments and economies. Cost estimates for states with such bills suggest significant financial burdens on taxpayers. In March 2023, President Biden vetoed a bill that would have restricted ESG considerations in investment decisions, highlighting the importance of ESG factors in financial markets.
This demonstrates that ESG is not merely a matter of preference; it is a financially material consideration. Climate change and other ESG issues present real risks and opportunities that businesses and investors cannot afford to ignore.
Wholesale distributors and industries with similar characteristics are not exempt from the growing importance of ESG. While the impact of ESG may vary across sectors, its relevance remains substantial.
- Supply Chain Sustainability: Wholesale distributors often manage extensive supply chains. ESG considerations in the supply chain, such as ethical sourcing and reducing environmental impact, are critical. Ensuring that products are sourced responsibly and transported efficiently can reduce costs and improve a company’s ESG profile.Â
- Energy Efficiency: Many wholesale distributors operate large warehouses and distribution centers. Implementing energy-efficient practices, including lighting, heating, and cooling systems, can lead to substantial cost savings and align with ESG Goals
- Product Sustainability: ESG extends to the products distributed. Wholesale distributors can benefit from offering sustainable and eco-friendly products, catering to the increasing demand from consumers and businesses for responsible choices.Â
- Stakeholder Engagement: Just like in other industries, stakeholder engagement is crucial. Understanding the ESG expectations of customers, investors, and employees can inform ESG strategy and help build trust.
- Regulatory Compliance: ESG-related regulations are evolving and may impact wholesale distributors. Staying compliant and proactive in addressing ESG requirements can mitigate legal risks.
The Navigation
- Skepticism: There is a need to emphasize that ESG is centered on financially material issues, including environmental, social, and governance aspects. It’s not about boycotts but about responsible investing and risk mitigation.

- ESG-oriented investors may avoid companies with large carbon footprints, but it doesn’t equate to a complete fossil fuel boycott. Instead, ESG encompasses a variety of sustainable investment strategies, including ESG integration, screening, best-in-class, and impact investing. Given the trajectory of emerging clean energy technologies and increased regulatory focus on decarbonization, ESG-oriented investors may look unfavorably at investing in the expansion of fossil fuel production.

- Fund Performance: While ESG funds had mixed performance in 2022, it’s important to note that their performance is often influenced by broader market conditions. Numerous studies show a correlation between ESG and improved financial performance over the long term. Despite short-term fluctuations, ESG is increasingly seen as a reliable indicator of long-term sustainability and profitability.
- Regulatory Oversight: Regulators are taking steps to prevent misleading ESG claims and improve transparency. The U.S. SEC, for instance, has issued alerts and rules to combat false ESG advertising, ensuring that investors have accurate and reliable information about ESG investments.
- State Legislation: Despite the ESG backlash, there are currently no known laws or regulations prohibiting companies from implementing ESG programs or communicating sustainability efforts. In fact, some states even mandate consideration of ESG or divestment from fossil fuels. This highlights the continued importance of ESG in the corporate landscape.

- Data Collection and Analysis: NetSuite can streamline the collection, validation, and analysis of financial and nonfinancial data related to ESG elements, facilitating transparency and reporting. This ensures that businesses have the data they need to make informed decisions and meet reporting requirements.

- Compliance and Legal Frameworks: With NetSuite, companies can establish effective internal controls and mechanisms to monitor compliance with ESG reporting requirements, guidelines, and industry standards. This reduces the risk of legal and regulatory violations while demonstrating a commitment to ESG.
- Operational Efficiency: NetSuite’s features can help improve energy and water efficiency, enhance asset resilience, and contribute to cost savings, aligning with ESG goals. By streamlining operations and optimizing resource use, businesses can reduce their environmental footprint.

- Stakeholder Engagement: Active engagement with stakeholders is crucial in evaluating ESG strategy. NetSuite can assist in identifying material ESG-related risks and opportunities across the company and incorporating them into the risk management processes and reporting framework.
